JAMA · 1970 · 122 citations · 0 references
MedicineClinical SciencesPathologyClinical MedicineClinical PathologyDiagnostic PathologyClinical AnalysisCytologyClinical Pathology InterpretationHistory Of Medical TechnologyPathology ReportsPathology-based DiagnosisTechnologies Of Diagnosis
In the competitive field of clinical pathology publishing, Saunders offers two comparable volumes—one targeting physicians with a focus on clinical diagnosis, the other aimed at technologists with a stronger emphasis on laboratory methods. Lynch et al succeed by skillfully blending theoretical concepts with practical details, a strategy necessitated by space constraints in multidisciplinary laboratory texts.
Like soap and cigarette manufacturers, publishing houses now have active competition among their own products. Saunders has two Big Books of clinical pathology running concurrently: the present volume, and theTodd-Sanford Clinical Diagnosis by Laboratory Methods, edited by Davidsohn and Henry. The two are altogether comparable in size and price. The titles provide an important clue to each book's goal. Davidsohn and Henry's title page emphasizesClinical Diagnosis, while Lynch et al stress the wordsMedical Laboratory Technology. By implication, the former is for the physician, the interpreter; the latter for the technologist, the doer. To a considerable degree this premise is true; more detailed and more numerous technical sections will be found in Lynch's book. A more important reason for Lynch et al's success is the skill with which the authors combine theoretical material with practical details. Pressures of space require all multidiscipline laboratory books to adopt a compact,