Comparative study of five instruments measuring stratum corneum hydration (Corneometer CM 820 and CM 825, Skicon 200, Nova DPM 9003, DermaLab). Part I. In vitro

Joachim W. Fluhr, M. Gloor, S. Lazzerini, Peter Kleesz, R. Grieshaber, Enzo Berardesca

Skin Research and Technology · 1999 · 126 citations · 21 references

Concepts

Abstract

Background/aims: The hydration state of stratum corneum can be measured with different instruments. In the present study, five instruments were compared under different experimental in vitro conditions: Corneometer CM 820 and CM 825, Skicon 200, Nova DPM and DermaLab. Methods: A sorption‐desorption test, measurements on different filters and with liquids with different dielectric constants, measurement‐depth analysis and measurements on different agar plates were performed. Results: Good correlation between the values of the five instruments and μl (sorption test: varying from r = 0.8249 to r = 0.9635) and time (desorption test: correlation varying from r = 0.7615 to r =0.9909) could be demonstrated. A high Spearman correlation coefficient ( r ) could be proven for dielectric constant (dc)/CM 820 ( r =0.9333), dc/CM 825 ( r =0.9833) and dc/Nova DPM ( r =0.9048). A lower correlation or no correlation was found for dc/DermaLab ( r =0.8469; P =0.023) and dc/Skicon 200 ( r =0.9000; P =0.083). Conclusions: For each of the five instruments, the electrical field of measurement can be assumed to cover the following depths: CM 820, between 30 and 45 μm; CM 825, around or less than 15 μm; Skicon 200, less than 15 μm; Nova DPM, between 45 and 60 μm; DermaLab, around or less than 15 nm.

References

21