Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · 1996 · 720 citations · 27 references
Social SciencesPsychiatryPsychologyClinical PsychologyCounseling PsychologyPsychotherapyCognitive Behavioral TherapyCounseling ProcessCounselor-client RelationshipDepression CounselingTherapeutic AllianceTreatment Of Mental DisordersAlliance PredictorsCognitive Behavior TherapyCognitive Therapy For DepressionCommon Factors TheoryCounselor-client AllianceDepression-cognition InteractionFocusTherapeutic Change Processes
The study examined whether process variables unique to cognitive therapy and common to other treatments predicted outcomes in 30 depressed clients receiving cognitive therapy with or without medication, and found that therapists’ increased use of cognitive rationales to address alliance problems was linked to a negative correlation with outcome. Improvement was predicted by the therapeutic alliance and client emotional involvement, while a unique cognitive therapy factor—therapists’ focus on distorted cognitions—negatively correlated with outcome by worsening alliance strains and impeding therapeutic change.
The ability of several process variables to predict therapy outcome was tested with 30 depressed clients who received cognitive therapy with or without medication. Two types of process variables were studied: 1 variable that is unique to cognitive therapy and 2 variables that this approach is assumed to share with other forms of treatment. The client's improvement was found to be predicted by the 2 common factors measured: the therapeutic alliance and the client's emotional involvement (experiencing). The results also indicated, however, that a unique aspect of cognitive therapy (i.e., therapist's focus on the impact of distorted cognitions on depressive symptoms) correlated negatively with outcome at the end of treatment. Descriptive analyses that were conducted to understand this negative correlation suggest that therapists sometimes increased their adherence to cognitive rationales and techniques to correct problems in the therapeutic alliance. Such increased focus, however, seems to worsen alliance strains, thereby interfering with therapeutic change.
27
An Inventory for Measuring Depression
Aaron T. Beck · Archives of General Psychiatry · 1961 · 38.2K citations
M. Hamilton · Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry · 1960 · 32.6K citations · Full text
Robert L. Spitzer · Archives of General Psychiatry · 1978 · 7K citations
Jean Endicott · Archives of General Psychiatry · 1976 · 5K citations