Emotion · 2011 · 140 citations · 49 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyIndividual DifferencesPersonality PsychologySocial CognitionDisposition EffectTrait TheoryAffectDirect CostsHedonic MotivationNegative AffectivityStroop InterferenceStroop Task PerformanceStroop Test
People enjoy acting extraverted, a tendency that appears to hold across the introversion–extraversion spectrum. The study investigates whether introverts can boost happiness by behaving extravertedly, while examining potential costs of this strategy. In two experiments, participants were randomly assigned to act introverted or extraverted, and researchers measured concurrent negative affect and Stroop task performance to assess emotional and cognitive costs. Results show that acting extraverted raises positive affect without increasing negative affect for all participants, yet counterdispositionally acting introverted leads to poorer Stroop performance only among extraverts, suggesting introverts can gain hedonic benefits while extraverts may face cognitive costs.
People enjoy acting extraverted, and this seems to apply equally across the dispositional introversion-extraversion dimension (Fleeson, Malanos, & Achille, 2002). It follows that dispositional introverts might improve their happiness by acting more extraverted, yet little research has examined potential costs of this strategy. In two studies, we assessed dispositions, randomly assigned participants to act introverted or extraverted, and examined costs-both emotional (concurrent negative affect) and cognitive (Stroop performance). Results replicated and extended past findings suggesting that acting extraverted produces hedonic benefits regardless of disposition. Positive affect increased and negative affect did not, even for participants acting out of character. In contrast, we found evidence that acting counterdispositionally could produce poor Stroop performance, but this effect was limited to dispositional extraverts who were assigned to act introverted. We suggest that the positive affect produced by introverts' extraverted behavior may buffer the potentially depleting effects of counterdispositional behavior, and we consider alternative explanations. We conclude that dispositional introverts may indeed benefit from acting extraverted more often and caution that dispositional extraverts may want to adopt introverted behavior strategically, as it could induce cognitive costs or self-regulatory depletion more generally.
49
Studies of interference in serial verbal reactions.
J. Ridley Stroop · Journal of Experimental Psychology · 1935 · 18.3K citations · Full text
James A. Russell · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · 1980 · 16K citations
Subjective well-being: Three decades of progress.
Ed Diener, Eunkook M. Suh, Richard E. Lucas et al. · Psychological Bulletin · 1999 · 11.2K citations