Bias in genomic predictions for populations under selection

Zulma G. Vitezica, Ignácio Aguilar, I. Misztal, Andrés Legarra

Genetics Research · 2011 · 399 citations · 27 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Genomic predictions of genetic merit or disease risk are increasingly used for livestock and plant selection, and their success depends on accuracy and lack of bias. The study examined how selection intensity and heritability affect bias and accuracy of genomic predictions in simulated animal populations. Genetic values were estimated by BLUP using either a multiple‑step method that summarizes relative data into pseudodata for genotyped individuals or a single‑step method that jointly uses genomic and pedigree relationship matrices. The multiple‑step method produced biased predictions, whereas the single‑step method was less biased and more accurate, though its accuracy declined under strong selection, and adjusting genomic relationships by an analytically derived constant eliminated bias and maximized accuracy.

Abstract

Summary Prediction of genetic merit or disease risk using genetic marker information is becoming a common practice for selection of livestock and plant species. For the successful application of genome-wide marker-assisted selection (GWMAS), genomic predictions should be accurate and unbiased. The effect of selection on bias and accuracy of genomic predictions was studied in two simulated animal populations under weak or strong selection and with several heritabilities. Prediction of genetic values was by best-linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) using data either from relatives summarized in pseudodata for genotyped individuals (multiple-step method) or using all available data jointly (single-step method). The single-step method combined genomic- and pedigree-based relationship matrices. Predictions by the multiple-step method were biased. Predictions by a single-step method were less biased and more accurate but under strong selection were less accurate. When genomic relationships were shifted by a constant, the single-step method was unbiased and the most accurate. The value of that constant, which adjusts for non-random selection of genotyped individuals, can be derived analytically.

References

27