Public transit performance: What does one learn from frontier studies?

Bruno De Borger, Kristiaan Kerstens, Álvaro Costa

Transport Reviews · 2002 · 244 citations · 45 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

This paper surveys literature on production and cost frontiers for public transit operators, assessing how frontier analysis enhances understanding of sector performance. The authors compare best‑practice and average‑practice technology specifications, review performance indicators and measurement methods, and systematically summarize and critique existing frontier studies of urban transit performance. They find that market organization, contract design, regulatory regime, and network characteristics drive inefficiency, yet many key issues in frontier analysis remain unresolved.

Abstract

This paper provides a comprehensive survey of the literature on production and cost frontiers for public transit operators, and it evaluates the contributions of frontier analysis to the understanding of the performance of the public transport sector. The authors first succinctly contrast best practice (or frontier) and average practice specifications of technology. They also review relevant performance indicators and the methods to measure them. Next, the existing frontier studies measuring urban transit performance are systematically summarized and critically assessed. It is shown that the organization of the market, contract design, the degree and nature of the regulatory regime, and the characteristics of the network being served are all important determinants of inefficiency. However, although the frontier literature has substantially contributed to the knowledge of urban transit technologies and the determinants of performance, it is found that many important issues remain unresolved.

References

45