Founding Faith: Providence, Politics, and the Birth of Religious Freedom in America

Marty McMahone

Journal of Church and State · 2009 · 47 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

If two groups are standing on opposite sides of a fence throwing rocks at each other, it can be very dangerous to try to walk down the fence line between them. There is a good chance of catching stones from both sides. Steven Waldman has done a masterful job of walking that gauntlet in the discussion of the place of religion in American society. In Founding Faith, Waldman tells the story of the American founding from the planting of the colonies to the passing of the First Amendment. The primary focus of his story, though, is on the development of the Constitution's protections of religious freedom through the stories of five key founders—Franklin, Jefferson, Madison, Washington, and Adams. Separationists and accommodationists alike tend to focus on selective quotations from these leaders that seem to disprove the other side's arguments while ignoring quotes that are uncomfortable for their own position. Waldman avoids this trap by planting his story in the historical context. He does this by bringing significant depth to the picture of the religious faith (or lack of it) of the founders and by showing the many compromises that were necessary to turn the idea of religious freedom into a law that would be acceptable throughout the country. Waldman acknowledges that many of the colonies developed with an intention to support Christianity, but he also notes that those attempts were largely failures. Most of the founders, together with their evangelical allies, recognized that using state power to support Christianity was bad for both the state and the church. On the other hand, the First Amendment compromises were possible at least partially because they were an exercise in federalism that allowed the states to maintain their support for religion.