Fractures Following Electroshock Therapy

James R. Lingley, Laurence L. Robbins

Radiology · 1947 · 29 citations · 1 references

Concepts

Abstract

The increasing use of convulsive therapy in various psychoses and allied disorders makes it necessary for the radiologist to be familiar with the roentgen changes that may be found in the complications associated with this form of treatment. The present study was undertaken in order to evaluate the traumatic complications (fractures) incident to electroshock therapy in a group of patients treated at the McLean Hospital. It is intended to emphasize the ways in which the radiologist can be of the greatest assistance to the psychiatrist and orthopedist. The therapeutic value of the treatment as it applies to the same group will not be discussed since it has been adequately presented elsewhere (8, 9). Since 1935, when Sakel in Vienna first reported insulin shock therapy for psychosis, the value of convulsive treatment has been more and more widely recognized, and the methods of producing shock have been investigated and expanded. Contraindications for and complications from this form of treatment were soon reported. In 1938 Stalker (7) in England and Wespi (10) from the continent each published case reports of severe fractures following convulsive therapy. Similar reports appeared in the American literature a year later. In 1939, Polatin and his associates (6) reported 51 cases of compression fracture of the thoracic vertebrae after metrazol treatment at the New York State Psychiatric Institute. This represented a 43.1 per cent incidence, with most of the cases showing multiple fractures. In all of them the thoracic vertebrae were involved, the number varying from one to eight. Since 1939 reports of like nature have been frequent. Drug or electroshock therapy undoubtedly produces convulsions that are often severe enough to cause dislocations and fractures not only of the vertebrae, but also of other parts of the bony structures of the body. Fracture of the pelvis, acetabulum, humerus, clavicle, and scapula have been observed. Dislocation of the jaw is not uncommon. The most frequent lesion, however, is in the spinal column, chiefly in the thoracic portion. The incidence of such fractures as reported by various investigators has ranged from zero up to 47 per cent of the patients treated. Different means for the prevention of the traumatic complications of shock therapy have been advocated—mechanical restraint, no restraint, hyperextension, spinal anesthesia, pre-shock paralyzing drugs, as curare and the like. To date none has been entirely successful. The published reports, both as to the incidence of fractures and as to the need of and the method for prevention, are extensive and contradictory. The consensus appears to be that, as a rule, vertebral fractures, except for pain, are relatively insignificant. Katzenelbogen and his colleagues (5) report the case of a patient who preferred fracture to his depression. Fracture of the long bones is a more serious complication, and fracture of the pelvis may be a cause of permanent disability.

References

1