Classification of river corridors: Issues to be addressed in developing an operational methodology

Angela M. Gurnell, P. G. Angold, K. J. Gregory

Aquatic Conservation Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems · 1994 · 23 citations · 5 references

Concepts

TL;DR

River corridor classification serves either to concisely describe river characteristics or to inform conservation and management decisions, yet data source heterogeneity introduces challenges of resolution, generalization, age, and standards. The study aims to develop a robust, widely applicable operational classification scheme based on a hierarchical structure that integrates diverse information types and resolutions for various applications. By analyzing 140 international publications, the authors identified trends toward multidisciplinary, small, hierarchical units, and propose a scheme that defines spatial units balancing natural and arbitrary boundaries, incorporates multiple data sources (field surveys, laboratory tests, thematic maps, remote sensing), and applies data‑handling rules to maintain raw‑data separation, consistent resolution, and appropriate aggregation. Integration of heterogeneous data sources into a classification can cause problems, and although GIS offers flexible integration, misuse of GIS functions can produce misleading results.

Abstract

Abstract The classification of river corridors may simply aim to describe what is there in a concise form or it may form a tool to support the assessment of conservation or enhancement potential and management decision‐making. An analysis of 140 international publications on river corridor classification illustrates temporal trends towards (i) multidisciplinary bases for classification related to (ii) increasingly small spatial units and spatially hierarchical structures, with (iii) the majority of the schemes being developed in North America and most of the remainder generated within Europe. An operational classification scheme that is robust and widely applicable will be based on a wide range of information types with a hierarchical structure incorporating different types and resolutions of information suitable to support classifications for different applications. In developing an operational scheme, spatial units for data handling must be defined which present a compromise between the natural boundaries representative of the character of the river corridor, and the environmentally arbitrary boundaries which often define the spatial units against which environmental data sets have been collected. A variety of data sources may support classification, including routine field surveys and laboratory determinations, thematic maps and remotely sensed information. Different sources present different problems of spatial resolution, generalization, age and changing data standards. Problems arise when data from different sources are integrated to derive a classification. GIS provides a flexible technology for such integration but the results may be misleading if GIS functions are not used intelligently. Data handling should (i) maintain separation between raw data and their derivatives, (ii) apply spatial aggregation or smoothing of data to a consistent spatial resolution prior to integration, and (iii) the spatial resolution selected should be appropriate for the hierarchical level to which it applies.

References

5