One versus two embryo transfer after IVF and ICSI: a randomized study

Hannu Martikainen, Aila Tiitinen, Candido Tomás, Juha S. Tapanainen, Mauri Orava, Leena Tuomivaara, Sirpa Vilska, Christel Hydén‐Granskog, Outi Hovatta

Human Reproduction · 2001 · 366 citations · 9 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Multiple pregnancies are a major adverse outcome in assisted reproduction, and transferring a single embryo is the only strategy to avoid dizygotic twins. In a randomized trial of 144 women with at least four high‑quality embryos, participants were assigned to transfer either one or two embryos, and treatment outcomes—including those after frozen transfers—were compared. The study found no significant difference in clinical pregnancy rates per transfer (32.4% vs 47.1%) or cumulative pregnancy per patient (47.3% vs 58.6%), but the two‑embryo group had more twin deliveries (11 vs 1 monozygotic), supporting single‑embryo transfer to maintain success while reducing dizygotic twins.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The main reason for adverse treatment outcome in assisted reproduction is the high rate of multiple pregnancies. The only strategy to avoid dizygotic twins is to transfer one embryo at a time. METHODS: A total of 144 women, who had had at least four good quality embryos available after IVF/intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) and who had no more than one previous failed treatment cycle, were randomized to have either one or two embryos transferred. The treatment outcomes including those after frozen embryo transfer were compared between these groups. RESULTS: The clinical pregnancy rate per transfer was 32.4% in the one embryo transfer group and 47.1% in the two embryo transfer group, the difference being not significant. Eleven twin deliveries (n = 39) occurred in the two embryo transfer group and there was one pair of monozygotic twins in the one embryo transfer group. The cumulative pregnancy rate per patient after transfer of fresh and frozen embryos was 47.3% in the one embryo transfer group and 58.6% in the two embryo transfer group. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that among women who have good quality embryos in their first IVF/ICSI, good treatment results can be achieved. They support the idea of changing embryo transfer policy towards one embryo transfer without any remarkable decrease in the success rate, while dizygotic twins can be avoided.

References

9