Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research · 2000 · 16 citations · 8 references
MedicineOrthopaedic SurgeryOrthopedic SurgeryEthicsMedical EthicsOrthopedicsDelphi StudiesEthical AssessmentProfessional ResponsibilityQuestionnaire DesignSurvey ProcessesDelphi Technique VariantsLikert Scale DesignLikert Scale DevelopmentLikert Scale ThresholdsLikert-type Scale InterpretationResearch Ethics Committees
At the Academic Orthopaedic Society meeting in San Francisco on November 8 and 9, 1996, the membership addressed the issue of ethics and industry in an academic setting. Using a Delphi panel technique, they arrived at a definition of conflict of interest, and 41 separate points of acceptable and unacceptable behavior related to gifts, research awards, and funding of various activities. The Academic Orthopaedic Society Delphi Committee also mailed 191 questionnaires (157 department chairpersons and 34 program directors) to 157 training programs. The respective department chairpersons and program directors were asked to copy and distribute the questionnaires to staff (faculty) and house officers (residents and fellows) to complete anonymously and return them for collation. Ninety-one programs (58%) responded. Three hundred and fifty-two questionnaires were returned (237 from staff, 115 from house officers), each of which expressed agreement or lack of agreement with the Delphi panel report using a Likert scale technique. With only modest (and usually predictable) disagreement on certain items, the final statements by the Delphi panel were supported strongly by the survive results. The Academic Orthopaedic Society believes that the major points arrived at by the panelists should serve as the basis for ethical guidelines in the relation between academic orthopaedic institutions and industry.
8
Consensus methods: characteristics and guidelines for use.
Alexander Fink, Jacqueline Kosecoff, M R Chassin et al. · American Journal of Public Health · 1984 · 2.1K citations
Peter J. Dean · Journal of Business Ethics · 1992 · 144 citations
Looking a Gift Horse in the Mouth
Eric G. Campbell, Karen Seashore Louis, David Blumenthal · JAMA · 1998 · 110 citations
Teaching medical ethics during residency
Henry S. Perkins · Academic Medicine · 1989 · 46 citations
Conflicts of Interest in Medical Center/Industry Research Relationships
JAMA · 1990 · 41 citations