A Simple Clinical Decision Rule To Rule Out Appendicitis In Patients With Nondiagnostic Ultrasound Results

Marjolein M. N. Leeuwenburgh, Hein B.A.C. Stockmann, Wim H. Bouma, Alexander P. J. Houdijk, Matthijs F. Verhagen, Bart C. Vrouenraets, Lodewijk P. J. Cobben, Patrick M. Bossuyt, Jaap Stoker, Marja A. Boermeester

Academic Emergency Medicine · 2014 · 42 citations · 27 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The objective was to identify a set of clinical features that can rule out appendicitis in patients with suspected acute appendicitis and nondiagnostic ultrasound (US) results, allowing safe discharge and next-day reevaluation without initial computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Data on clinical and US evaluation, including a number of prespecified variables potentially associated with acute appendicitis, were prospectively collected in two diagnostic accuracy studies of imaging. These studies included patients with suspected appendicitis seen in the emergency department (ED). For development and validation of the clinical decision rule (CDR), only patients with inconclusive or negative US results were included. There were 199 (of 422) patients in the development cohorts and 120 (of 211) patients in the validation cohort. Logistic regression analysis was used for data from patients with inconclusive or negative US results, and profiles were created of all possible combinations of predictors retained in the multivariable model. A final diagnosis was assigned by an expert panel based on perioperative data, histopathology, and clinical follow-up of at least 3 months. The CDR selected patients after negative or inconclusive US for discharge and next-day reevaluation without initial CT or MRI if fewer than two of the following predictors were present: male sex, migration of pain to the right lower quadrant, vomiting, and white blood cell (WBC) count higher than 12.0 × 109/L. Applying the CDR in the development set selected 126 of 199 (63%) patients with negative or inconclusive US results for discharge without further imaging. This rule reduced the probability of appendicitis from 26% (51 of 199) in the total group of patients with negative or inconclusive US results to 12% (15 of 126) in the group that would be discharged based on the rule (p = 0.001). In the validation set (n = 120), the decision rule selected 72 (60%) patients for discharge and next-day reevaluation and reduced the probability of appendicitis from 20% (24 of 120) in the total group to 6% (4 of 72) in the patients selected on the rule (p = 0.001). The negative predictive value of the decision rule in the validation set was 94% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 87% to 98%). In comparison, the negative predictive value of CT in the same group was 99% (95% CI = 93% to 100%, p = 0.14), and that of MRI was 99% (95% CI = 94% to 100%, p = 0.12). Alternative decision rules based on combinations of the present decision rule with C-reactive protein (CRP) results did not improve selection. This newly developed CDR significantly reduces the probability of appendicitis in a large subgroup of patients with negative or inconclusive US results. These patients can be safely discharged for outpatient reevaluation without further initial imaging if proper follow-up is available. This could assist in lowering the number of ED imaging investigations in patients with suspected appendicitis. Identificar un conjunto de hallazgos clínicos que pueda descartar una apendicitis en pacientes con sospecha de apendicitis aguda y resultados ecográficos no diagnósticos, de manera que permitan dar de alta de forma segura y reevaluarlos al día siguiente sin una tomografía computarizada (TC) o resonancia magnética (RM) inicial. Se recogieron de forma prospectiva datos sobre la evaluación clínica y la ecografía, que incluía un número de variables prestablecidas potencialmente asociadas con apendicitis aguda, en dos estudios de precisión de diagnóstico por imagen. Estos estudios incluyeron a pacientes con sospecha de apendicitis visitados en el servicio de urgencias (SU). Se incluyeron sólo los pacientes con resultados ecográficos negativos o no concluyentes para el desarrollo y la validación de la regla de decisión clínica (RDC). Hubo 199 pacientes (de 422) en la cohorte de desarrollo, y 120 pacientes (de 211) en la cohorte de validación. Se utilizó un análisis de regresión logística para los datos de pacientes con resultados ecográficos negativos o no concluyentes, y se crearon los perfiles de todas las posibles combinaciones de factores predictivos introducidos en el modelo multivariable. Se asignó un diagnóstico final por un panel de expertos en base a los datos de la cirugía e histopatológicos y del seguimiento clínico durante al menos tres meses. La RDC seleccionó pacientes tras una ecografía negativa o no concluyente para dar de alta y reevaluar al día siguiente sin una TC o una RM inicial si presentaban al menos dos de los siguientes factores predictivos: sexo masculino, migración del dolor al cuadrante inferior derecho, vómitos y recuento de leucocitos por encima de 12,0 × 109/L. Aplicando la RDC en la cohorte de desarrollo, se seleccionó a 126 de 199 (63%) pacientes con resultados ecográficos negativos o no concluyentes para dar de alta sin más pruebas de imagen. Esta regla redujo la probabilidad de apendicitis de un 26% (51/199) en el grupo total de pacientes con resultados ecográficos negativos o no concluyentes, a un 12% (15/126) en el grupo que se habría dado de alta basándose en la regla (p = 0,001). En la cohorte de validación (n = 120), la regla de decisión seleccionó a 72 (60%) pacientes para dar de alta y reevaluar al día siguiente, y redujo la probabilidad de apendicitis de un 20% (24/120) en el grupo total a un 6% (4/72) de los pacientes seleccionados basándose en la regla (p=0,001). El valor predictivo negativo de la regla de decisión en la cohorte de validación fue de un 94% (intervalo de confianza [IC] 95% = 87% a 98%). En comparación, el valor predictivo negativo de la TC en el mismo grupo fue de un 99% (IC 95% = 93% a 100%, p = 0,14), y el de la RM fue de un 99% (IC 95% = 94% a 100%, p = 0,12). Las reglas de decisión alternativas basadas en las combinaciones de la presente RDC inicial junto con resultados de proteína C-reactiva no mejoraron la selección. Esta RDC recientemente desarrollada reduce significativamente la probabilidad de apendicitis en un gran subgrupo de pacientes con resultado ecográfico negativo o no concluyente. Estos pacientes pueden ser dados de alta de forma segura para reevaluar de forma ambulatoria sin más pruebas de imagen iniciales si se dispone de un correcto seguimiento. Esto podría ayudar a reducir el número de pruebas de imagen en el SU en pacientes con sospecha de apendicitis. CME Editor: Corey Heitz, MD Authors: Marjolein M. N. Leeuwenburgh, MD, PhD, Hein B. A. C. Stockmann, MD, PhD, Wim H. Bouma, MD, PhD, Alexander P. J. Houdijk, MD, PhD, Matthijs F. Verhagen, MD, Bart Vrouenraets, MD, PhD, Lodewijk P. J. Cobben, MD, PhD, Patrick M. M. Bossuyt, PhD, Jaap Stoker, MD, PhD, and Marja A. Boermeester, MD, PhD, on behalf of the OPTIMAP Study Group* Article Title: A Simple Clinical Decision Rule To Rule Out Appendicitis In Patients With Nondiagnostic Ultrasound Results If you wish to receive free CME credit for this activity, please refer to the website: http://www.wileyhealthlearning.com/aem. Accreditation and Designation Statement: Blackwell Futura Media Services designates this journal-based CME activity for a maximum of 1 AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM. Physicians should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity. Blackwell Futura Media Services is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education to provide continuing medical education for physicians. Educational Objectives After completing this exercise the participant will be better able to describe the development, validation, and clinical utility for a decision rule regarding the management of appendicitis in the setting of a negative or nondiagnostic ultrasound. Activity Disclosures No commercial support has been accepted related to the development or publication of this activity. Faculty Disclosures: CME Editor: Corey Heitz, MD, has no relevant financial relationships to disclose. Authors: Marjolein M. N. Leeuwenburgh, MD, PhD, discloses institutional research support from the Dutch Organization for Health Research and Development, Health Care Efficiency Research program (Zon Mw). Marja A. Boermeester, MD, PhD discloses institutional research support from the Dutch Organization for Health Research and Development, Health Care Efficiency Research program (Zon Mw), as well as grants to her institution from Abbott, Baxter, Ipsen, LifeCell, and GSK. Jaap Stoker, MD, PhD, discloses institutional research support from the Dutch Organization for Health Research and Development, Health Care Efficiency Research program (Zon Mw) and consulting for Robarts Clinical Trials. Hein B. A. C. Stockmann, MD, PhD; Wim H. Bouma, MD, PhD; Alexander P. J. Houdijk, MD, PhD; Matthijs F. Verhagen, MD; Bart Vrouenraets, MD, PhD; Lodewijk P. J. Cobben, MD, PhD; and Patrick M. M. Bossuyt, PhD, have no relevant financial relationships to disclose. This manuscript underwent peer review in line with the standards of editorial integrity and publication ethics maintained by Academic Emergency Medicine. The peer reviewers have no relevant financial relationships. The peer review process for Academic Emergency Medicine is double-blinded. As such, the identities of the reviewers are not disclosed in line with the standard accepted practices of medical journal peer review. Conflicts of interest have been identified and resolved in accordance with Blackwell Futura Media Services's Policy on Activity Disclosure and Conflict of Interest. Instructions on Receiving Free CME Credit For information on applicability and acceptance of CME credit for this activity, please consult your professional licensing board. This activity is designed to be completed within an hour; physicians should claim only those credits that reflect the time actually spent in the activity. To successfully earn credit, participants must complete the activity during the valid credit period, which is up to two years from initial publication. Follow these steps to earn credit: This activity will be available for CME credit for twelve months following publication that will be and potentially and for an twelve months. The of imaging has reduced the negative in patients suspected of in the of In this group diagnostic imaging is or to diagnostic imaging to clinical of all patients with suspected of clinical pain and a predictive value for are present in only a of patients suspected of This the clinical diagnosis of appendicitis in the of and the for imaging in patients suspected of appendicitis. studies have that the of imaging has a on with two lower negative with imaging in all to of imaging based on clinical The imaging for patients suspected of appendicitis has been in tomography (CT) has been to be than ultrasound is associated with the of CT have been developed with lower of for further of without diagnostic accuracy are A of initial US with CT in of negative or inconclusive US results has been to in a higher in in patients with acute pain to a In a only of patients would US and This CT is standard in in the studies that magnetic resonance imaging could CT in a imaging the of CT in and the The of a is that patients have to two in higher imaging and to identify a set of clinical features that can rule out appendicitis in patients suspected of appendicitis have inconclusive or negative US patients would not CT or MRI after US in a imaging of a clinical decision rule based on these features could reduce the number of imaging without This was a to a CDR based on data collected in patients with suspected acute appendicitis development data and to in a set of patients with suspected acute appendicitis validation data The medical ethics of the the of studies to included patients Data for the development data set of the CDR were collected to the value of and CT after clinical in patients with acute pain in the This is in and a total of patients with for than and than were identified at the emergency in of two Medical and Medical and large and in the patients in this underwent US and suspected acute appendicitis and data to the development set = = to Data for the validation data set of the CDR were collected in diagnostic accuracy that imaging with US and CT after inconclusive or negative US and MRI in patients with suspected appendicitis. In this all patients imaging after inconclusive or negative US results. This OPTIMAP has been in patients were included and in Medical and large and in the patients with suspected acute appendicitis with for than and than their data the validation set = = to In the studies that were used for the development set and validation the were to patients of of the The appendicitis did not significantly the For the development and the validation physicians in the ED prospectively collected data with a in a patients were all from medical sex, of of pain in the right lower migration of pain to pain on of in and protein in white blood cell count in were patients underwent US by a or the their US to the their as for for not or or for No for the diagnosis of appendicitis were the for diagnosis was at the of the A final diagnosis was assigned by an expert of two and after at least 3 was based on all and imaging and clinical variables to be associated with acute appendicitis based on were in the development set in patients with inconclusive or negative For the diagnostic for a final diagnosis of acute appendicitis, with 95% confidence interval regression with appendicitis, with an of 1 of an The variables were as such, without that were associated with appendicitis in analysis (p were included in a multivariable regression model. of a for to at a model. The of the final multivariable after was by the the an of or higher to With the variables associated with acute appendicitis in the final multivariable developed profiles of all possible These profiles were by or all of the variables in the final multivariable model. In this process for the retained variables were For possible of the variables in the the number of patients with that and the number of patients with final of appendicitis in With these of and negative predictive value for the The would identify a subgroup of patients with all of acute appendicitis. If were able to identify a subgroup based on a the not the be discharged without that subgroup would not appendicitis at a rule that would identify a large group of patients with a of appendicitis than that a rule with an of at least the of the and the of patients with that selected the to a decision For comparison, of the of the decision rule were to the of CT and MRI in the same set of is used in clinical and studies have a in the for acute appendicitis in of and an decision rule was based on combinations of the developed decision rule with for the decision rule in patients with inconclusive US results and negative US results imaging only in patients with inconclusive After development of the CDR in the development data was in the validation data used only data of patients with inconclusive or negative The data of the development set were to those in the validation to if of sex, and clinical variables were were the for and the for were to For the of the CDR was with the final as assigned by the expert In this of the and could be with 95% For comparison, of the of the decision rule were to the of CT and MRI in the same set of were the were In the US appendicitis in of patients in the development 199 patients with inconclusive or negative US for the development The results of the of potentially associated with appendicitis in this group are in of these clinical predictors for the multivariable model. After predictors were sex, migration of pain to the vomiting, and count The of this multivariable is in The is (95% CI = to With combinations of the predictors retained in the multivariable migration of pain to vomiting, developed profiles for patients in the development set in US was negative or inconclusive In 3 the number of patients appendicitis as final diagnosis is patients with appendicitis as final diagnosis (n = two or of the associated with with at least two predictors and patients with fewer than two on the of appendicitis in of the to these the following decision rule was to rule out appendicitis in patients with inconclusive or negative US results refer for imaging if a with suspected appendicitis and an inconclusive or negative US has two or of the male sex, migration of pain to vomiting, or count 12.0 × discharge and the The in the development set after of the decision rule is in Appendicitis was the final diagnosis in of 199 patients with inconclusive or negative US results in the development The decision rule selected 126 of 199 (63%) patients for discharge and next-day reevaluation and of 199 for imaging. The of appendicitis was reduced to of 126 in the of in the imaging This that the decision rule reduced the probability of appendicitis from of 199 in the total group to of 126 in the subgroup that would be discharged (p The for appendicitis of the decision rule in the development of patients with inconclusive or negative US results, was (95% CI = to The of a negative of the rule was (95% CI = to and the of a rule was (95% CI = to In comparison, the of CT was 93% (95% CI = to in this group of this was not significantly higher (p = The of a negative CT was (95% CI = to and a of a CT was (95% CI = to decision rules based on combinations of the developed decision rule with results. for imaging if a with suspected appendicitis and an inconclusive or negative US has two or of the male sex, migration of pain to vomiting, and count 12.0 × discharge and the This rule selected of 199 of patients for discharge without imaging in the development of of appendicitis If patients were selected for imaging only in of or of the of 199 patients could be discharged without of of appendicitis. the 199 patients of the development data inconclusive US results of those and patients negative US results of Applying the decision rule to the patients with inconclusive US results would only of of patients for with of appendicitis, and of for with of those appendicitis. In the patients with negative US results, the rule would of patients for with of appendicitis, and out of for with of those appendicitis. In the rule reduced the probability of appendicitis from to in patients with inconclusive US (p = and from to in patients with negative US (p = The of the rule was in patients with inconclusive US and patients with negative US (p = In the OPTIMAP of patients US results. The 120 patients with inconclusive or negative US results data to the validation The development and validation were with to the of sex, clinical and of appendicitis and p = Patients in the development set were = years p = and the results of US were for acute appendicitis in the development set p = The in the validation set after of the decision rule is in In the validation of 120 patients with inconclusive or negative US results appendicitis as their final Applying the CDR would discharge 72 patients and would patients for imaging. The rule reduced the probability of appendicitis from of 120 in the total group to of 72 in the subgroup that would be discharged (p In the imaging the probability of appendicitis was of The of the decision rule in the validation set was 94% (95% CI = 87% to 98%). The of a negative rule was (95% CI = to and the was (95% CI = to In comparison, the of CT was 99% (95% CI = 93% to 100%, p = 0.14), and that of MRI was 99% (95% CI = 94% to 100%, p = 0.12). The of a negative CT was (95% CI = to and that of a negative MRI was (95% CI = to a CT a of (95% CI = to and that of a MRI was (95% CI = to The decision rule in with in of two or selected of 120 patients for discharge and next-day reevaluation and reduced the probability of appendicitis from of 120 to of p = If patients were selected for imaging in the of or of the the rule selected of 120 of patients for discharge and reduced the probability of appendicitis from of 120 in the total group to of p = in the selected developed a CDR in patients with suspected appendicitis and nondiagnostic can a large subgroup of patients for discharge (60%) with a probability of appendicitis and no for further imaging. appendicitis of 12% and not be in not have to the following This rule used only clinical male sex, migration of pain to the vomiting, and count higher than 12.0 × 109/L. The of did not improve results of the decision The decision rule reduced the probability of appendicitis in patients with inconclusive US and in patients with negative the of the rule was higher in patients with a negative In the development data set and the validation data the of the decision rule identified a large subgroup with a and significantly lower probability of appendicitis. The of the decision rule was to that of CT or The reduced probability of appendicitis in the subgroup that was selected for discharge without imaging is not for safe of these patients in the outpatient setting the following for In the only clinical was used to patients with suspected appendicitis. The to refer for an was a appendicitis, and the associated was to be than a negative As a negative up to have been 12% of patients with appendicitis are clinical is not by in and an of have been developed to identify patients suspected of acute appendicitis based on clinical The for acute appendicitis are the and the appendicitis The was based on features in the as a The claim that their can the of patients those can be for outpatient and those to be on a number of patients with results diagnostic imaging. these have not acceptance in clinical an validation of the appendicitis A that an and an are is a in the for acute For this in with the developed decision model. In was not associated with acute appendicitis in and multivariable the of to rule with predictors did not These results that is not a in patients suspected of appendicitis have negative or inconclusive US results, to sex, migration of pain to the vomiting, or only imaging in patients with inconclusive US results and not in patients with negative This could to a of imaging to a with standard CT after negative and inconclusive which is based on the results of the In data set a would of 199 patients with negative US for in of of appendicitis. In comparison, the decision rule selected 126 of 199 (63%) of patients for discharge with a 12% (15/126) probability of appendicitis. the predictive value of US as as that of a negative US has been to have a significantly higher of to is that the accuracy of US is on the and of the and have been to In the be during US and the of of appendicitis be A that of in the and of the has a of only US only not to appendicitis in patients have clinical of appendicitis based on clinical and The development data set and the validation data set were not selected from a from two imaging in two time As a US results were in the development This be for of the in of the decision rule the development set and the validation CDR patients with inconclusive or negative US results in two and next-day reevaluation and an be for the of clinical in must be that the of the decision rule is not to a diagnosis of appendicitis, to assist further imaging is after the The rule was developed in patients with suspected acute appendicitis, and based on in the probability of appendicitis. did not the probability of in the development of this that patients with suspected appendicitis have that as or these patients from imaging could diagnosis and in In a large of patients inconclusive in the used for the development and in the used for the This could be by the that the were in a diagnostic accuracy and did not to by negative as negative in the in the of an inconclusive or a negative US would be by The a negative or inconclusive did not have clinical for the of a negative US the would The decision rule could assist in lowering the number of imaging investigations in patients with suspected appendicitis. final can be and utility should be further This could be in a management in which the rule is in a and time by a higher number of patients to be would be to patients with suspected appendicitis and a negative or inconclusive ultrasound to the decision rule or to standard imaging.

References

27