The Diagnosis of Pericardial Effusion with Intracardiac Carbon Dioxide

James H. Scatliff, Alfred J. Kummer, Arnold H. Janzen

Radiology · 1959 · 60 citations · 3 references

Concepts

Abstract

In 1837 Cormack (1) reported that he blew the contents of his twice-filled chest into the jugular vein of a horse and that the animal exhibited “only moderate signs of uneasiness.” This probably represents the first time that the right heart of any animal experienced more than its usual quota of carbon dioxide. Needless to say, physicians have felt considerable uneasiness in the intervening one hundred and twenty years when any free gas arrived in the heart. In the last two years intracardiac carbon dioxide has been shown to be of definite diagnostic aid in cardiovascular radiology. Experimental animal studies by Oppenheimer et al. (2) in 1955 revealed that relatively large amounts of this gas could reach the right heart and pulmonary circulation without producing embolic phenomena. Human application was first carried out by Stauffer (3), who visualized the heart valves and chambers in two infants. In the course of these studies Durant, Stauffer, Paul, and Oppenheimer (4, 5) found that carbon dioxide in the right atrium could be used to differentiate pericardial effusion from cardiac enlargement. The limitations of plain-film examination in this problem are well known. Kymography may show blunting of pulsations in both entities, and fluoroscopy in the recumbent position may demonstrate widening of the base of the cardiac silhouette in both. Opaque angiography will reveal the presence of surrounding pericardial effusion but carries with it the risk of allergic reaction. Reliance on pericardiocentesis to establish the diagnosis entails the hazard of myocardial laceration and hemopericardium. In order, therefore, to evaluate the carbon-dioxide method, a series of 22 patients have now been examined by the authors. It is with the rationale, technic, results, and safety of intravenous carbon-dioxide insufflation that this paper deals. Rationale It has been pointed out that carbon dioxide is twenty times more soluble in blood than oxygen or air. This property of the gas allows the formation of a transient gas-blood level and serves as the crux of the method. It may be calculated that small intravenous injections of carbon dioxide, 50 to 100 C.C., alter the carbon-dioxide content of the blood approximately 5 to 10 volumes per cent, and this effect is of only several minutes duration. In this time the change produced in the blood pH is insignificant. This amount of carbon dioxide is equivalent to the amount of the gas formed in one minute during minimal exercise, such as eating or turning over in bed. If a patient is placed in left decubitus (left side down, right side up), carbon dioxide, once in the right atrium, will rise and outline its uppermost surface. In this position the atrium is seen as a hemispherical shadow extending at its summit 4 to 5 cm. above the spine. The opaque shadow or band, as we have come to call it, outlined between the carbon-dioxide bubble and the overlying lung, consists of pleura, pericardium, and atrial wall.

References

3