International Journal of Reliability and Safety · 2009 · 13 citations · 7 references
EngineeringAutomotive EngineeringSafety EngineeringVehicle Safety EngineeringVehicle ValidationCrash SimulationCrash TestingReliability ValidationRoad SafetySafety ValidationTraffic SafetyAcceptance CriteriaComputational Prediction ModelsFull-scale Crash TestingFull-scale TestingValidation MetricsValidation Metrics SelectionValidation Of Crash ModelsValidation Of Crash Simulation Models
This paper proposes acceptance criteria for quantitative comparison metrics to be applied in the Verification and Validation (V&V) process of computational models used in roadside safety. Typically, the degree of verification or validation of a numerical model is assessed by qualitatively comparing the shapes of two curves, but qualitative comparisons are subjective and open to interpretation. Using quantitative comparison metrics in the V&V process allows for an objective measure of the reliability of a numerical model. Two comparison metrics were selected from a group of 16 metrics found in the literature. Acceptance criteria suitable to the typical scatter of full-scale crash tests were established by comparing ten essentially identical vehicle redirectional crash tests. Since the tests were as identical as can be achieved experimentally, the values of the quantitative metrics represented the reasonable range for the metric corresponding to matched experiments. Typical residual errors expected in full-scale tests are also discussed.
7
Carl F. Christ, Henri Theil · Econometrica · 1962 · 1K citations
Business, Economics, Economic Policy +11