Statistical Science · 1987 · 196 citations · 4 references
ComputingComputer ScienceMathematicsArtificial IntelligenceProbability TheoryUncertainty QuantificationDecision Under UncertaintyDecision-making Under UncertaintyExpert SystemsProbability ConceptsUncertainty ReasoningUncertainty RepresentationBelief FunctionsProbabilistic LogicProbabilistic ReasoningProbabilistic RepresentationReasoning About UncertaintyUncertainty AssessmentUncertainty HandlingUncertainty In Decision Making
Uncertainty is best described by probability, defined both mathematically and as a degree of belief. The paper argues that probability can outperform all alternative methods for handling uncertainty. The authors develop probability’s coherence through axioms and scoring rules, illustrate it with fuzzy logic and belief function examples, and conclude with a forensic case.
Arguments are adduced to support the claim that the only satisfactory description of uncertainty is probability. Probability is described both mathematically and interpretatively as a degree of belief. The axiomatic basis and the use of scoring rules in developing coherence are discussed. A challenge is made that anything that can be done by alternative methods for handling uncertainty can be done better by probability. This is demonstrated by some examples using fuzzy logic and belief functions. The paper concludes with a forensic example illustrating the power of probability ideas.
4