Directing Wayfinders With Maps: The Effects of Gender, Age, Route Complexity, and Familiarity With the Environment

W. Andrew Harrell, Jeffrey W. Bowlby, Deana Hall-hoffarth

The Journal of Social Psychology · 2000 · 46 citations · 17 references

Concepts

TL;DR

360 Canadian undergraduates were given written scenarios of a campus visitor needing directions to a simple or complex route, drew maps, and the authors varied the visitor’s gender, age, and familiarity while analyzing map content for cardinal indicators, landmarks, labeled buildings, directional arrows, and supplemental directions. Men produced more cartographically complete maps, were more likely to consider visitor characteristics, and reported greater confidence, while complex routes increased use of landmarks, labeled buildings, and cardinal indicators, and familiarity had little effect except for more labeled buildings.

Abstract

Abstract The participants were 360 Canadian undergraduates. After receiving written scenarios involving a campus visitor seeking direction to a nearby destination (simple route) or a distant destination (complex route), they drew maps to that destination. The authors varied the visitor's gender, age, and familiarity with campus. They analyzed the content of the students' maps in terms of cardinal indicators (compass grid, correct north-south orientation), landmarks, labeled buildings, directional arrows, and supplemental written directions. The men tended to provide more cartographically complete maps than the women, though there were no gender differences in use of landmarks or labeled buildings. The men were significantly more inclined than the women to take visitor characteristics into account, providing more complete maps to visitors navigating complex routes, to newcomers, and to older visitors who were unfamiliar with the campus. The men had more confidence that their maps would successfully lead visitors to their destinations. Route complexity led to greater use of landmarks, labeled buildings, and cardinal indicators. The participants' self-reported familiarity with campus had little effect on their direction giving, except for a greater use of labeled buildings in maps.

References

17