Judicial Policies: Implementation and Impact

Dagmar Hamilton, Charles A. Johnson, Bradley C. Canon

Journal of Policy Analysis and Management · 1984 · 246 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Judicial Policies, updated after fourteen years, evaluates how judicial rulings are implemented, their impact, and consequences, while addressing new research since the first edition. The book investigates how judicial decisions affect implementers, affected parties, and the broader political system, using a heuristic model to explain implementation and subsequent events, and questions the judiciary’s overall influence. The authors employ a heuristic model of population responses to explain judicial policy implementation, subsequent events, and to structure the literature. They provide examples showing both significant and negligible court influence.

Abstract

Widely praised in its first edition fourteen years ago and now thoroughly updated in a new edition, Judicial Policies assesses the implementation, impact, and consequences of judicial rulings. It systematically explores the effects of judicial decisions on the people who carry them out, and the individuals and organizations who feel their impact. This second edition discusses and responds to the significant research that has been published since the first edition appeared. Arguing that judicial policies in the United States are substantially influenced by how the courts and other political actors respond, authors Canon and Johnson employ a heuristic model of different populations and their responses to judicial decisions as a means of: explaining the implementation of judicial policies as a political process, examining the events that usually follow judicial decisions, and organizing the literature in the field. The concluding chapter addresses the important question of whether the judiciary actually makes a difference in the American political system. Canonical and Johnson delineate examples where the courts have clearly had an impact and those where they have had little influence.