BMJ · 1954 · 36 citations · 1 references
MedicineDermatologyRadiation OncologyCutaneous OncologyRadiobiologyRodent MedicineRadiation TherapyRadiobiological ConsiderationsRadiotherapy For Skin CancerRodent DermatologyRodent PathologyRadiation Effects On The SkinRadium TherapySurgical Cure RatesVeterinary Radiation Therapy
Many papers have been published on the subject of rodent ulcers and their treatment by radiotherapy; in all those we have examined there is almost complete agreement on the excellent results produced, from the point of view of both cure and cosmetic appearance, in early lesions not previously treated. Some papers give no cure rate at all; others mention it in what can only be described as an expression of opinion, since it is unsupported by figures and at first sight these cure may appear unduly optimistic to a non-radio therapeutic eye. Finzi (1933), for example, stated: the early stages, the method of radium treatment advised will cure 99% of cases. Windeyer (1951) said: The great majority of all rodent ulcers occurring on the skin of the face or neck are treated by radiotherapy, and if they are still free from involvement of underlying bone or cartilage they are curable . . . to the order of 95% by this means. That there is justification for these high percentages is seen by a study of other works, which give figures showing clearly how the cure rate is arrived at. In 1935 Magnusson gave 93.3% + 2 as his highest estimated three-year cure rate for superficial lesions, using mainly radium. In 1946 Mustakallio's net three-year cure rate for superficial lesions less than 1 cm.2 was 97.8%, using both x rays and radium. Stanford Cade's (1952) three year cure rate for a series of Stage I (involving skin and subcutaneous tissue only) rodent ulcers treated from 1925 to 1937 was 98%, using radium only. The highest disease-free rate for Stage I basal-cell carcinomata men tioned by the National Radium Commission (1937-8) is 99%. It must be emphasized, however, that these cure rates refer to early lesions only and to treatment mainly by radium. The use of different methods of expressing results is one of the factors that make precise comparison of the above percentages very difficult. How much more diffi cult, then, is it to compare results of whole series, each of which is made up of lesions at all stages of develop ment. Although no attempt at comparison is made here, the results of three centres are shown in Table I, and readers are referred to the original works for further information. In stating the excellence of the results of radiothera peutic treatment of basal-cell carcinomata most papers lay emphasis on the part played by radium. It was therefore felt that the time had come to demonstrate the results of x-ray therapy and to show that equally satisfactory results could be obtained with suitable x ray techniques, which on the whole are easier to apply than radium and subject the patients to less inconveni TABLE I.-Results of Three Centres in the Treatment of Rodent Ulcers by Radiotherapy
1
The X-ray Treatment of Accessible Cancer
I. Davidsohn · American Journal of Clinical Pathology · 1947 · 15 citations