Millennium Journal of International Studies · 2014 · 101 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesConflict StudiesMilitary HistorySecurity StudiesWar StudiesBattle StudiesMethods Of WarfareMilitary DoctrineMilitary StrategyWar TheoryClausewitzian Theory
Current scholarship largely defines war as fighting, but this paper argues for a shift toward viewing war as processing. The study aims to show that some aspects of war are no longer defined by combat encounters. The authors illustrate this by analyzing how the repetitive battle‑rhythm of military targeting seeks a perfect war. The analysis concludes that war has become a reified concept that obscures its own disappearance, and the debate itself reinforces this reification.
Against a surprising level of agreement between Clausewitz, contemporary military doctrines and critical war studies on an ontology of war as fighting, we suggest that the study of contemporary warfare needs to focus more on war as processing. Through Jean Baudrillard we argue that at least some of what is referred to as ‘war’ is no longer characterised by encounters through fighting. We exemplify our argument by how the repetitive battle-rhythm of military targeting strives for perfect war. What remains is not war as an object in itself, but a reified ‘war’ that obscures the disappearance of that very object. The debate on war contributes to the reification of such a war, as an imperative telling us: ‘we have a concept, you must learn to think through it’.