Excess mortality on the liver transplant waiting list: Unintended policy consequences and model for End‐Stage Liver Disease (MELD) inflation

Patrick G. Northup, Nicolas M. Intagliata, Neeral L. Shah, Shawn J. Pelletier, Carl L. Berg, Curtis K. Argo

Hepatology · 2014 · 190 citations · 12 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The MELD allocation system for liver transplantation grants exceptions for conditions such as hepatocellular carcinoma. The study aimed to evaluate the balance between exception and non‑exception candidates on the waiting list and to determine whether the exception system drives rising regional MELD scores at transplant. Researchers analyzed 78,595 adult liver transplant candidates from 2005 to 2012, examining yearly waiting‑list characteristics, transplantation rates, and regional variations in how exceptions influence regional MELD scores at transplant. Candidates with exceptions comprised 27.3% of the waiting list, had shorter wait times (237 vs 426 days), higher transplantation rates (79.1% vs 40.6%), lower death rates (4.5% vs 24.6%), and the proportion of HCC exceptions was the strongest predictor of regional MELD scores at transplant, indicating that the exception system largely drives increasing MELD scores independent of geography. Published in Hepatology 2015;61:285–291.

Abstract

The Model for End‐Stage Liver Disease (MELD) allocation system for liver transplantation provides “exceptions” for diseases such as hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). It was the aim of this study to assess equipoise between exception candidates and nonexception candidates on the waiting list and to assess if the exception system contributes to steadily increasing regional MELD at transplant. In all, 78,595 adult liver transplant candidates between January 2005 and December 2012 were analyzed. Yearly trends in waiting list characteristics and transplantation rates were analyzed for statistical association with MELD exceptions. Regional variations in these associations and the effect of exceptions on regional MELD scores at transplant were also analyzed. 27.29% of the waiting list was occupied by candidates with exceptions. Candidates with exceptions fared much better on the waiting list compared to those without exceptions in mean days waiting (HCC 237 versus non‐HCC 426), transplantation rates (HCC 79.05% versus non‐HCC 40.60%), and waiting list death rates (HCC 4.49% versus non‐HCC 24.63%). Strong regional variation in exception use occurred but exceptions were highly correlated with waiting list death rates, transplantation rates, and MELD score at removal in all regions. In a multivariate model predicting MELD score at transplant within regions, the percentage of HCC MELD exceptions was the strongest independent predictor of regional MELD score at transplant. Conclusion : Liver transplant candidates with MELD exceptions have superior outcomes compared to nonexception candidates and the current MELD exception system is largely responsible for steadily increasing MELD scores at transplant independent of geography. (H epatology 2015;61:285–291)

References

12