Does Kant Demand Explanations for All Synthetic A Priori Claims?

Colin Marshall

Journal of the history of philosophy · 2014 · 56 citations · 43 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Kant’s philosophy promises to explain various synthetic a priori claims. Yet, as several of his commentators have noted, it is hard to see how these explanations could work unless they themselves rested on unexplained synthetic a priori claims. Since Kant appears to demand explanations for all synthetic a priori claims, it would seem that his project fails on its own terms. I argue, however, that Kant holds that explanations are required only for synthetic a priori claims about (purportedly) experience-independent entities, and that his project rests on a rationalist method of reflection that justifies certain basic synthetic a priori claims.

References

43