Disappearance of the Mueller-Lyer Illusion under Prolonged Inspection

James Selkin, Michael Wertheimer

Perceptual and Motor Skills · 1957 · 18 citations · 1 references

Concepts

Abstract

This experiment partially repeated studies by Koehler and Fishback ( I ) , who found that the size of the Mueller-Lyer illusion decreased with prolonged inspection, and that fixation tended to hasten this disappearance. In the present study, a different apparatus, with luminous rather than illuminated figures, was used. Scheduling of inspection periods also was different. The apparatus consisted of a cardboard screen on which a fixation point and cut-outs forming the four arrowheads of the illusion were mounted. The lines of the arrowheads, at an angle of 60 to one another, were 3/g un. wide and 3% cm. long. These were separately illuminated from the rear by means of flashlight bulbs powered by dry-cell batteries. A calibrated scale, placed alongside the cut-outs on the rear of the screen, was used to measure the size of the illusion. The two outward-pointing arrowheads were placed near the top of the screen, with the left arrowhead adjustable horizontally. The two inward-pointing arrowheads were placed at a vertically adjustable distance below these, and slightly to the right. S was seated 6 ft. from the screen, and adjusted the apparatus by means of strings. The room was dark, except for a weak red light behind the screen, used to illuminate the controls and facilitate recording by E, who sat behind the screen and could not be seen. 6 Ss adjusted the illusion (horizontally) during a 2-min. pretest period while fixating. Ss 1, 2, and 3 were then exposed to the illusion for three 2-min. periods, during which they adjusted the lower figure to a given arbitrary vertical distance from the upper figure, while maintaining fixation. S 4 followed the same instructions, except that he was asked not to fixate. Ss 5 and 6 merely fixated the illusion for 3 2-min. periods, without making adjustments. After a 1-min. rest period, all Ss again adjusted the illusion to equality (horizontally) while fixating for a 2-min. period. Ss went through the procedure on a Monday, the next Wednesday, and again the following Monday. Despite such major changes In procedure and apparatus, our findings seemed similar to those of Koehler and Fishback. 5 of the 6 Ss (all but S 6, who showed an increase) demonstrated a clear reduction in the size of the illusion. Variations in fixation and adjustment did not, however, produce any appreciable

References

1