Achievements and Barriers in the Organ Donation Process: A Critical Analysis of Donation Coordinators' Discourse

Francisco Javier Mercado-Martínez, Blanca Alejandra Díaz-Medina, Eduardo Hernández-Ibarra

Progress in Transplantation · 2013 · 14 citations · 12 references

Concepts

Abstract

CONTEXT: Donation coordinators play an important role in the success or failure of organ donation and transplant programs. Nevertheless, these professionals' perspectives and practices have hardly been explored, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. OBJECTIVE: To examine donation coordinators' discourse on the organ donation process and the barriers they perceive. DESIGN: A critical qualitative study was carried out in Guadalajara, Mexico. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Twelve donation coordinators from public and private hospitals participated. DATA GATHERING AND ANALYSIS: Data were gathered by using semistructured interviews and critical discourse analysis. RESULTS: Participants indicated that partial results have been achieved in deceased organ donation. Concomitantly, multiple obstacles have adversely affected the process and outcomes: at the structural level, the fragmentation of the health system and the scarcity of financial and material resources; at the relational level, nonegalitarian relationships between coordinators and hospital personnel; at the ideational level, the transplant domain and its specialists overshadow the donation domain and its coordinators. Negative images are associated with donation coordinators. CONCLUSIONS: Organ donation faces structural, relational, and ideational barriers; hence, complex interventions should be undertaken. Donation coordinators also should be recognized by the health system.

References

12