PS Political Science & Politics · 1990 · 31 citations · 2 references
Social SciencesPolitical SciencePublic PolicyPolitical SociologyDemocracyElectionsPolitical Ideology
What is the nature of contemporary political science? What shared concerns bind us together as a discipline, providing a common definition and direction to our intellectual enterprise? These questions were on my mind as I organized the section on formal and normative political theory for the 1989 APSA meetings. Initially, I had wanted to sponsor a panel to address the nature of formal and normative theory. I knew I was a bit uncertain about the precise nature of these fields and sensed that other scholars shared my desire for greater clarity. Then I read Gabriel Almond's Separate Tables (PS: Political Science and Politics, 1988). The surprisingly diverse and intense reaction this article generated in the profession suggested the confusion extended beyond my own subfield and into the discipline as a whole. All of this provided the impetus for the round table whose discussion is summarized below. Since Almond's article argues there is a methodological separateness that limits us as a discipline, I tried to choose panel discussants to reflect the disparate parts of political science. I spoke with each panelist in advance and, drawing on their suggestions, I constructed and circulated a few key questions around which our discussion would be organized. As is obvious in the following remarks, panelists expressed quite different views, but each participant touched on the following questions in some way: Is there a core to contemporary political science? If so, what is it? If not, does its absence matter? Should there be a core? And how important is communication among the different branches of political science? Each panelist made a brief statement on this topic, focusing on these particular questions. Their remarks are reprinted below, with their per-
2
Rationalism in Politics, and other Essays.
Dorothy Emmett, Michael Oakeshott · The Philosophical Quarterly · 1963 · 287 citations