Evidence & Policy · 2007 · 17 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesSociologyComparative Effectiveness ResearchOutcomes ResearchSocial PhilosophyQualitative Research MethodsSocial EpistemologySocial EvaluationSocial ScienceTheory-based EvaluationEffectiveness EvaluationEffectiveness ResearchOntological AnalysisRelational OntologySocial Ontology
English This article first applies the yardstick developed by Bruno Latour for studying the ontological approaches used in the social studies of science to three mainstream approaches to effectiveness research in the social sphere: positivism, social constructivism and realistic evaluation. An alternative to the dualistic ontology of effectiveness research is then developed. The relational approach sees the world as materially heterogeneous networks and relations (socio-material, socio-technical) that are continually performed and (re)constituted by human and non-human elements. A brief hypothetical illustration of how this ontological standpoint might be reflected in the practice of effectiveness research is then presented.