American Ethnologist · 2012 · 62 citations · 43 references
HumanitiesJurisprudenceReligious StudiesIslamic StudiesPhilosophy Of LawSociological JurisprudenceIslamic LawJudicial BehaviorJudicial Decision-makingLegal AnthropologyLegal EthicsRule Of LawJudicial BureaucracyJudicial CultureJudicial RulesReligious VocationTragic Hero
ABSTRACT In this article, I present ethnography of judicial practice in Lebanon's shari'a courts and find a tension between the identity of the judges presiding as Islamic religious specialists and their identity as legal professionals. Just applying the rules of the law is incompatible with true religious vocation, which demands personal engagement with the morally needy. But to ignore legal strictures is to be dismissed as a mere sermonizer. I find this case illustrative of a deeper tension between the use of rules and the disciplining of virtuous selves and argue for a new anthropology of rules to set alongside the new anthropology of ethics. [ bureaucracy, ethics, Islam, law, Lebanon, rules, shari'a court ]
43
Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject
Salwa Ismail · American Anthropologist · 2006 · 4.1K citations
From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology
Sam Thorne, Hans H. Gerth, Charles W. Mills · The Yale Law Journal · 1946 · 3.7K citations
After Virtue; A Study in Moral Theory
Nancy S. Struever, Alasdair MacIntyre · MLN · 1981 · 2.7K citations