Information Systems Research · 2000 · 117 citations · 34 references
Social SciencesInformation SystemsManagement Information SystemsCross-cultural ManagementDiscourse AnalysisEthnographyCross-cultural ComparisonEthnographic InterviewingEthnographic MethodsEthnographic ResearchQualitative Research MethodsCross-cultural Data CollectionEmic ApproachEmic-etic ApproachEtic ApproachGrounded Theory AnalysisGrounded Theory Interview AnalysisGrounded Theory InterviewingQualitative Interviewing
Cross‑cultural factors are increasingly critical as businesses expand globally, especially within the rapidly evolving information systems field. The article aims to present qualitative research issues, contrast emic and etic approaches, and introduce a structured yet flexible interview technique that reduces researcher bias. It describes a grounded‑theory method based on Kelly’s Repertory Grid, which uses laddering in one‑to‑one interviews to elicit detailed participant constructs while maintaining flexibility for personal interpretation. The authors illustrate the technique with projects comparing perceptions of “excellent” systems analysts across two cultures and argue that RepGrid effectively addresses key methodological challenges in cross‑cultural IS research.
As more business is being conducted internationally and corporations establishthemselves globally, the impact of cross-cultural aspects becomes an important research issue. The need to conduct cross-cultural research is perhaps even more important in the relatively newly emerging and quickly changing information systems (IS)field. This article presents issues relating to qualitative research, emic versus etic approaches, and describes a structured, yet flexible, qualitative research interviewing technique, which decreases the potential for bias on the part of the researcher. The grounded theory technique presented in this article is based on Kelly's Repertory Grid (RepGrid), which concentrates on “laddering,” or the further elaboration of elicited constructs, to obtain detailed researchparticipant comments about an aspect within the domain of discourse. The technique provides structure to a “one-to-one” interview. But, at the same time, RepGrids allow sufficient flexibility for the research participants to be able to express their own interpretation about a particular topic. This article includes a brief outline of a series of research projects that employed the RepGrid technique to examine similarities and differences in the way in which “excellent” systems analysts are viewed in two different cultures. Also included is a discussion of the technique's applicability for qualitative researchin general and cross-cultural studies specifically. The article concludes by suggesting ways in which the RepGrid technique addresses some of the major methodological issues in cross-cultural research.
34