Journal of American History · 2002 · 423 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesGender StudiesHistoryFeminist TheorySocial MovementsWomen's HistoryFeminist MovementsModern Women's HistoryRadical FeminismWomen's ActivismWomen's MovementsWomen's Social HistoryHistory Of FeminismSecond-wave FeminismWomen In Social MovementsWomen's Activism HistoryWomen's Labor MovementsWomen's Liberation MovementWomen's Local HistoryWomen’s Liberation Movements
Rosen’s history of second‑wave feminism focuses on the experiences of young, white, left‑leaning women, portraying a bleak 1950s marked by pervasive antifeminism and revising the standard narrative of feminist streams. The book shows that NOW and local women’s liberation groups differ in ways that defy simple liberal‑radical or integrationist‑transformative labels, highlighting working‑class and race‑conscious roots and that NOW focused on ordinary working women rather than professionals.
Ruth Rosen has written a deeply researched and engaging, but also highly selective, history of second-wave feminism. Because the ideas and experiences of young, white, educated, left-leaning women—such as Rosen, herself an activist in the Berkeley area—drive the narrative, a more instructive subtitle would be “How a Critical Element of the Women's Movement Helped Change America.” Rosen paints a picture of the 1950s even bleaker than Betty Friedan's. “A virulent strain of antifeminism saturated the culture,” she writes, creating bitterness, depression, and a “private nightmare” for more than a few women, at least according to their daughters, themselves experiencing “quiet desperation.” Although she follows the standard narrative explaining the origins of two feminist streams in the mid-1960s, Rosen offers important revisions. She delineates differences between women involved in the National Organization for Women (now) and those in the local women's liberation groups, while also demonstrating that they do not neatly fit the categories of liberal versus radical or integrationist versus transformative. moreover, she documents the working-class origins and race-conscious perspective of many activists in both wings and notes that NOW “targeted the problems of ordinary working women, not those of professional women.”