On Topological Issues of Indeterminism

Tomasz Placek, Nuel Belnap, Kohei Kishida

Erkenntnis · 2013 · 24 citations · 13 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Indeterminism, the idea that an event can unfold in multiple alternative ways, raises the question of what a region of chanciness looks like, a question that emerges in both the Montague‑Lewis‑Earman conceptualization and the branching tradition of Prior, Thomason, and Belnap. The authors investigate the topological and spatiotemporal aspects of indeterminism, abstracting from the specific mechanisms of chancy processes. They study indeterminism within Belnap’s branching space‑time framework, defining topologies on the model and its histories, specifying light‑cone structures under four conditions, and focusing on the Hausdorff property. They prove that every history in a branching model is Hausdorff, and that the entire model’s Hausdorff property is tied to passive indeterminism, which they describe in detail.

Abstract

Indeterminism, understood as a notion that an event may be continued in a few alternative ways, invokes the question what a region of chanciness looks like. We concern ourselves with its topological and spatiotemporal aspects, abstracting from the nature or mechanism of chancy processes. We first argue that the question arises in Montague-Lewis-Earman conceptualization of indeterminism as well as in the branching tradition of Prior, Thomason and Belnap. As the resources of the former school are not rich enough to study topological issues, we investigate the question in the framework of branching space-times of Belnap (Synthese 92:385–434, 1992). We introduce a topology on a branching model as well as a topology on a history in a branching model. We define light-cones and assume four conditions that guarantee the light-cones so defined behave like light-cones of physical space-times. From among various topological separation properties that are relevant to our question, we investigate the Hausdorff property. We prove that each history in a branching model satisfies the Hausdorff property. As for the satisfaction of the Hausdorff property in the entire branching model, we prove that it is related to the phenomenon of passive indeterminism, which we describe in detail.

References

13