Extended Topological Metrics for the Analysis of Power Grid Vulnerability

Ettore Bompard, Enrico Pons, Di Wu

IEEE Systems Journal · 2012 · 161 citations · 23 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Power‑grid vulnerability analysis relies on complex‑network metrics, yet purely topological measures miss the electrical characteristics that link topology to physical behavior. This study proposes an extended betweenness centrality that integrates electrical distance, power‑transfer distribution, and line‑flow limits to better assess component importance in power grids. The authors define the extended betweenness from the topological concept, then compare it against topological betweenness and average line power flow across multiple operational states of the Italian power grid. Results show that the extended betweenness outperforms topological betweenness in identifying critical components and can complement electrical‑engineering vulnerability analyses.

Abstract

Vulnerability analysis in power systems is a key issue in modern society and many efforts have contributed to the analysis. Recently, complex networks metrics, applied to assess the topological vulnerability of networked systems, have been used in power grids, such as the betweenness centrality. These metrics may be useful for analyzing the topological vulnerability of power systems because of a close link between their topological structure and physical behavior. However, a pure topological approach fails to capture the electrical specificity of power grids. For this reason, an extended topological method has been proposed by incorporating several electrical features, such as electrical distance, power transfer distribution, and line flow limits, into the pure topological metrics. Starting from the purely topological concept of complex networks, this paper defines an extended betweenness centrality which considers the characteristics of power grids and can measure the local importance of the elements in power grids. The line extended betweenness is compared with the topological betweenness and with the averaged power flow on each line over various operational states in the Italian power grid. The results show that the extended betweenness is superior to topological betweenness in the identification of critical components in power grids and at the same time could be a complementary tool to efficiently enhance vulnerability analysis based on electrical engineering methods.

References

23