Justice Quarterly · 1989 · 407 citations · 122 references
Social SciencesCriminologyPsychologyDevelopmental PsychologyDevianceJuvenile JusticeBiasDevelopmental Trajectories Of OffendingJuvenile DelinquencySymbolic InteractionismTheory Of DevianceYouth DevianceAttributesInteractionist Theory Of DevianceJuvenile Delinquency AdjudicationJuvenile Delinquency TrajectoriesLabelingProtective Factors In DelinquencyStatus Characteristics TheoryYouth Delinquency
Labeling theory was influential in the 1960s and 1970s but faced critiques that led to its perceived demise by 1985, although many critiques misrepresent the theory. This paper investigates labeling theory’s application to juvenile delinquency, elaborating its hypotheses, proposing empirical tests, and reviewing the existing literature. The authors ground labeling theory in conflict theory and symbolic interactionism, then formulate two key hypotheses: that status characteristics influence labeling and that labeling experiences foster secondary deviance. They conclude that labeling theory remains viable and call for its restatement and revitalization in delinquency research. The authors thank anonymous reviewers and editor Frank Cullen for their contributions.
The labeling theory of deviance was extremely popular during the 1960s and 1970s. After a series of influential critiques, however, the validity of the theory had fallen into question by 1980 and was pronounced dead by 1985. In this paper we examine the application of the labeling perspective to one particular area, juvenile delinquency. We discuss the general theoretical origin of labeling theory in both conflict theory and symbolic interactionism, and use it to present two main labeling hypotheses: 1) that status attributes are influential in determining who is labeled (the “status characteristics hypothesis”) and 2) that labeling experiences are instrumental in producing problems of adjustment and in causing subsequent commitment to further deviance (the “secondary deviance hypothesis”). We note that what is often passed off as a critique of labeling theory itself is frequently a caricature of the theory. The major point of the paper is an elaboration of the full complexity of each labeling hypothesis, a suggestion for empirical research to test it, and a review of the extant literature. We suggest that labeling theory is not as invalid as its critics have claimed, and that what is needed is a restatement and revitalization of a labeling theory of delinquency. We are most grateful to the three anonymous reviewers of this article and to the editorial efforts of Frank Cullen. We are most grateful to the three anonymous reviewers of this article and to the editorial efforts of Frank Cullen. Notes We are most grateful to the three anonymous reviewers of this article and to the editorial efforts of Frank Cullen.
122
Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error
James J. Heckman · Econometrica · 1979 · 28.9K citations
The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
Kaspar D. Naegele, Erving Goffman · American Sociological Review · 1956 · 26.2K citations
The Social Construction of Reality
Daniel M. Rose, Peter L. Berger, Thomas Luckmann · Modern Language Journal · 1967 · 14K citations
A Social Psychologist Discovers Chicago Sociology
Edgar H. Schein, Everett C. Hughes, Melville Dalton et al. · Academy of Management Review · 1989 · 7.2K citations
Attribution theory in social psychology
Harold H. Kelley · 1967 · 3.5K citations