Competitive ability is related to metabolic asymmetry in juvenile rainbow trout

Abstract

Of 55 size–matched pairs of juvenile rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss , each consisting of one high and one low relative metabolic rate fish (relative size difference <5%), the high relative metabolic rate fish was dominant in 36 pairs (65·5%), significantly more often than expected by chance. The probability of a fish winning was related to its relative metabolic rate (measured prior to introduction into the test arena); the higher the relative metabolic rate of a fish compared to its opponent, the greater its probability of being dominant. In the 36 pairs of fish where the low relative metabolic rate fish was the subordinate, its competitive ability was significantly correlated with how closely the two fish were matched in terms of their relative metabolic rates. The smaller the difference between the relative metabolic rates of the dominant high relative metabolic rate fish and subordinate low metabolic rate fish, the greater the competitive ability and feeding success of the low relative metabolic rate subordinate. However, no such relation was found in the 19 pairs of fish where the high relative metabolic rate fish was the subordinate. In these pairs, the competitive ability of the subordinate high relative metabolic rate fish was correlated with its size relative to its dyad partner. The larger the dominant low relative metabolic rate fish, the lower the competitive ability of the subordinate high relative metabolic rate fish.