Diversity and Stability of Ecological Communities: A Comment on the Role of Empiricism in Ecology

TLDR

The diversity‑stability hypothesis posits that species diversity stabilizes community function through compensatory interactions that buffer environmental fluctuations, a concept often misunderstood by ecologists. Empirical data from old‑field perturbations and Serengeti‑Mara grasslands confirm the hypothesis at the primary producer level and show that the traditional verbal model outperforms recent mathematical formulations.

Abstract

The diversity-stability hypothesis developed over the past 25 years appears widely misunderstood by ecologists, although it simply states that species diversity mediates community functional stability through compensating interactions to environmental fluctuations among co-occurring species. Fluctuations in the abundances of species with different adaptive modes may be a mechanism stabilizing community function in a varying environment. The available empirical evidence, including data from an experimental perturbation of successional old fields and data on the impact of environmental fluctuations on properties of grasslands in the Serengeti-Mara ecosystem of Tanzania and Kenya, suggests that the hypothesis is true at the primary producer level. As components of natural science, models are true only insofar as they are verified as accurate descriptions of the systems they purportedly characterize. The data on diversity-stability relationships in plant communities indicate that the traditional verbal model is considerably more robust in application than recent "more rigorous" mathematical models.