American Antiquity · 1992 · 86 citations · 30 references
HumanitiesArchaeologyPhilosophyCultural HistoryHermeneuticsPrehistoric ArchaeologyArchaeological ContextHistorical HermeneuticsArchaeological InterpretationHermeneutic TraditionHermeneutics Of HistoricityHermeneutics Of HistoryInterpretive Archaeology
In this paper we situate and discuss critically Ian Hodder's contextual archaeology in relation to a broader tradition of philosophical hermeneutics. We argue that Hodder's position comes close to the romantic conception of interpretation developed by German philosophers and historians. Central to this position is the equation of meaning and intention, context and origin, making historical understanding a transaction between the creative consciousness of the prehistoric agents and the receptive or reconstructive consciousness of the archaeologist. Drawing on Gadamer's critique of early hermeneutics we argue that Hodder's contextual archaeology disregards the dialectic between past and present horizons, a dialectic embedded in past material culture itself lying before us as present traces of a past.
30
Hans‐Georg Gadamer, Garrett Barden, John Cumming et al. · International Journal for Philosophy of Religion · 1977 · 2.2K citations
<i>A History of Archaeological Thought</i>. By Bruce G. Trigger.
David B. Small · American Journal of Archaeology · 1992 · 1.3K citations
Humanities, Archaeology, History +11
Gadamer, Hermeneutics, Tradition and Reason
Kieran Flanagan, Georgia Warnke · British Journal of Sociology · 1989 · 842 citations
Social Theory and Archaeology.
Robert Chapman, Michael Shanks, Christopher Tilley · Man · 1988 · 783 citations