Evaluating automatically estimated chord sequences

Abstract

In this paper, we perform an in-depth evaluation of a large number of algorithms for chord estimation that have been submitted to the MIREX competitions in 2010, 2011 and 2012. Therefore we first present a rigorous scheme to describe evaluation methods in a sound, unambiguous way that extends previous work specifically to take into account the large variance in chord estimation vocabularies and to perform evaluations on select sets of chords. Then we take a look at the evaluation metrics used so far and propose some alternative ones. Finally, we use these different methods to get a deeper insight into the strengths of each of the competing algorithms and show that the choice of evaluation measure greatly influences the ranking.