Anthrozoös · 2012 · 130 citations · 39 references
AgricultureAnimal SciencesAnimal WelfareCompanion Animal ScienceSmall Animal MedicineAnimal EthicsAnimal Research EthicsAnimal StudiesAnimal Welfare AssessmentAlternatives To Animal TestingAnimal Testing AlternativesAnimal-assisted Therapy WelfareConstruct ValidityConstruct Validity AssessmentEfficacy In Animal ModelsTherapeutic Human-animal Relationships
Animal‑assisted therapy and activities use a nonhuman animal as a key therapeutic agent, ranging from highly specified interventions to more casual ones. The review investigates whether a live animal is essential for therapeutic success in animal‑assisted therapy. The authors examined two meta‑analyses and 28 empirical studies to evaluate the animal’s role. The findings suggest that AAT and AAA effects are likely moderate and broad, but current evidence is insufficient to conclusively determine whether a live animal is necessary for therapeutic benefit.
Animal-assisted therapy and animal-assisted activities involve a nonhuman animal as a key therapeutic agent in some kind of intervention that may range from highly specified, as in AAT, to more casual, as in AAA. In this review I address the question: How important is the animal in animal therapy? In other words, does the recent literature strongly support the notion that a live animal, as opposed to another novel stimulating component, is specifically necessary for therapeutic success. Two meta-analyses and 28 single empirical studies were reviewed in order to address this issue. I conclude that the effects of AAT and AAA are likely to be moderate and broad at best and that, although improving, the literature has not yet reached an experimentally rigorous enough level to provide a definitive robust conclusion about the effectiveness of these approaches, particularly with regard to the question of whether a live animal is necessary for a therapeutic effect.
39
Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change
Edward F. Sanford · American Journal of Psychotherapy · 1988 · 2.6K citations
Education, Counseling, Psychology +12
Animal-Assisted Therapy: A Meta-Analysis
Janelle Nimer, Brad Lundahl · Anthrozoös · 2007 · 705 citations
Research Methods in Psychology
Journal of Environmental Psychology · 1994 · 426 citations