EXCESS RETURNS OF INDEX REPLACEMENT STOCKS: EVIDENCE OF LIQUIDITY AND SUBSTITUTABILITY

Abstract

Abstract Excess returns of S&P index replacement stocks are attributed to price pressures and imperfect substitutes in previous research. However, parameter estimates are biased by the use of pre‐announcement returns; replacements are characterized by rising stock prices. Using a future estimation period to avoid this bias, we find excess returns do not reverse. Further, we find no relation between excess returns and the amount of stock closely held or the size of index funds. The evidence supports efficient market assumptions: the stock market is liquid and stocks are close substitutes.