Public Health Ethics · 2009 · 43 citations · 4 references
HumanitiesPublic Health EthicsEthicsMedical EthicsMoral PsychologyApplied EthicsAutonomyConsentMoral PhilosophyNormative EthicsConsent In Research EthicsEthical Aspects Of ConsentIndividual ConsentPublic Health Research EthicsRight To Consent
This article first describes a dilemma for liberalism: On the one hand restricting their own options is an important means for groups of people to shape their lives. On the other hand, group members are typically divided over whether or not to accept option-restricting solutions or policies. Should we restrict the options of all members of a group even though some consent and some do not? This dilemma is particularly relevant to public health policy, which typically target groups of people with no possibility for individuals to opt out. The article then goes on to propose and discuss a series of aggregation rules for individual into group consent. Consideration of a number of scenarios shows that such rules cannot be formulated only in terms of fractions of consenters and non-consenters, but must incorporate their motives and how much they stand to win or lose. This raises further questions, including what is the appropriate impact of altruistic consenters and non-consenters, what should be the impact of costs and benefits and whether these should be understood as gross or net. All these issues are dealt with in a liberal, anti-paternalistic spirit, in order to explore whether group consent can contribute to the justification of option- restricting public health policy.
4
Just health: meeting health needs fairly
Choice Reviews Online · 2008 · 855 citations
Harry Brighouse, Marc Fleurbaey · Journal of Political Philosophy · 2008 · 269 citations · Full text
Richard J. Arneson · Ethics · 1980 · 126 citations
The Normative Core Of Paternalism
Kalle Grill · Res Publica · 2007 · 55 citations · Full text
Humanities, Philosophy, Ethics +6