Information Communication & Society · 2014 · 329 citations · 40 references
Social SciencesCommunicationPolitical CommunicationMass CommunicationPolitical BehaviorPolitical Communication Research MethodsPolitical DiscussionSocial MediaSocial Media PoliticsImpoliteness In Online DiscourseOnline Political DiscussionOnline Social InteractionPolitical Communication OnlinePolitical Discussion OnlinePolitical News CoverageSocial Media Political CommunicationSocial Media Political Discussion
News organizations have turned to Facebook to clean up comment sections by making users identifiable and accountable for their content. The study hypothesizes that commenting via a Facebook profile reduces engagement in uncivil and impolite discussion, even on politically sensitive topics. By analyzing political news discussions on the Washington Post’s Facebook page versus its website, the authors compare the level of civility when users are identifiable versus anonymous. Results show that discussions on the Washington Post website are significantly more uncivil and more often directed at other participants than those on its Facebook page.
In an effort to clean up user comment sections, news organizations have turned to Facebook, the world's largest social network site, as a way to make users more identifiable and accountable for the content they produce. It is hypothesized that users leaving comments via their Facebook profile will be less likely to engage in uncivil and impolite discussion, even when it comes to discussing politically sensitive and potentially divisive issues. By analysing the content of discussion as it occurs in response to political news content on the Washington Post Facebook, and comparing it to that which occurs on the Washington Post website where users are afforded a relatively high level of anonymity, the present study determines the extent to which Facebook increases the level of civility and impoliteness in an area of political discussion renowned for uncivil and impolite communicative behaviour. In line with earlier theories of social interaction, the paper finds that political discussion on The Washington Post website is significantly more likely to be uncivil than discussion of the same content on the Washington Post Facebook page. Moreover, the incivility and impoliteness on the Washington Post website are significantly more likely to be directed towards other participants in the discussion compared to The Washington Post Facebook page.
40
The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data
J. Richard Landis, Gary G. Koch · Biometrics · 1977 · 78.9K citations · Full text
Nebraska Symposium on Motivation
J. R. Wittenborn · The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease · 1959 · 1.9K citations