The Balance of Nature? Ecological Issues in the Conservation of Species and Communities

TLDR

Ecologists often study too few species, small areas, and short time frames, limiting their ability to address large‑scale ecological problems, a critique that Pimm highlights in *The Balance of Nature?*. The book poses new theoretical questions and urges a partnership between theoretical and empirical ecology to tackle pressing conservation challenges. Pimm outlines five types of ecological stability—strict stability, resilience, variability, persistence, and resistance—to compare natural populations, communities, and ecological theories.

Abstract

Ecologists, although they acknowledge the problems involved, generally conduct their research on too few species, in too small an area, over too short a period of time. In The Balance of Nature?, a work sure to stir controversy, the distinguished theoretical ecologist Stuart L. Pimm argues that ecology therefore fails in many ways to address the enormous ecological problems now facing our planet. Ecologists describing phenomena on larger scales often use terms like stability, balance of nature, and fragility, and Pimm begins by considering the various specific meanings of these terms. He addresses five kinds of ecological stability--stability in the strict sense, resilience, variability, persistence, and resistance--and shows how they provide ways of comparing natural populations and communities as well as theories about them. Each type of stability depends on characteristics of the species studied and also on the structure of the food web in which the species is embedded and the physical features of the environment. The Balance of Nature? provides theoretical ecology with a rich array of questions--questions that also underpin pressing problems in practical conservation biology. Pimm calls for nothing less than new approaches to ecology and a new alliance between theoretical and empirical studies.