Notes · 1997 · 12 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesMusicologyCritical TheoryMusic SociologyMusic TheoryAesthetic Theories Of MusicMusic HistoriographyAutonomous Meaning In MusicFeminist Critiques Of ImperialismFeminist Critiques Of MarxismFeminist Critiques Of PsychoanalysisMusical Canon CritiqueMusical Semiotics
Critical musicology continues to encounter hostility within academy, yet there can be no doubt that emergence of this subdiscipline has brought about a sea change in scholarship. Whether or not one agrees with scholars such as Rose Subotnik, Lawrence Kramer, and Susan McClary, social contingency of autonomous is no longer seriously questioned; rather, debate has shifted to how this social contingency is to be interrogated. Each of these scholars has focused on different aspects of question: Subotnik has explored ties of musical logic to post-Enlightenment critiques of reason, Kramer has emphasized importance of hermeneutics and contingency of postmodern knowledge, while McClary has offered feminist critiques of Western canon based on assumptions of music's underlying semiotic structure. (1) These scholars have been ambitious, productive, and ultimately successful in their pursuit of a new agenda for musicology. Despite these impressive achievements, project of critical musicology continues to carry serious risks. The reliance upon metaphor always leaves these scholars vulnerable to charge of substituting a narrative programme for substantive analysis, and because critical musicologists acknowledge that their scholarship is positioned, they have been accused of failing to demonstrate veracity of their claims and of thus willfully imposing a social interpretation on autonomous music. While it is tempting to dismiss these criticisms as simply carping of reactionaries, to do so would be a mistake. Scholars such as Charles Rosen and Pieter van den Toorn may be unsympathetic to project of critical musicology, but that stance alone does not disqualify their objections. (2) If they have not been convinced by arguments of critical musicologists, perhaps it is because arguments are insufficiently grounded, relationship between autonomous and society inadequately developed. Indeed, critical musicology is in danger of undermining itself through a lack of attention to problem of mediation--the concrete links between and society on levels of production and reception. How are scholars to account for complex mediations between musical text and social world of politics and economics? One strategy has been to interrogate social contingency of musical form, assailing autonomous at its root. Social interpretation is developed by relating separate domains cognitively through extended use of analogy, with consequence that and society ultimately remain separate, related only through imagination of critic and reader. Yet, mere assertions of social contingency are ultimately unpersuasive, even when these assertions are argued powerfully through use of metaphor. Empirical evidence must be provided to substantiate these interpretive claims, demonstrating concrete connections between musical work and its social context. Another strategy has been to investigate as a social practice, If meaning is created, how is it created, by whom, and through what means? How does creation of musical meaning connect to acquisition of power? How do these activities connect further on level of class? This approach is very promising, yet it is insufficient simply to raise these questions in absence of a coherent theoretical framework. As ethnomusicologists have known all along, problem of mediation cannot be solved by simply juxtaposing the sociology of music against the sociology of musical life; interrelationships between two spheres are too complex to permit such an obvious reduction. To be sure, if autonomous bears social significance, this must be demonstrated through musical analysis; however, such analysis may prove to be little more than passionate rhetoric if problem of mediation is ignored. Ironically, though critical musicologists have been faulted for being too sociological, I will argue that they have not been sociological enough. …