Craft Secrecy in Europe in the Early Modern Period: A Comparative View

Karel Davids

Early Science and Medicine · 2005 · 34 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Craft secrecy is a quintessentially hybrid theme. Lying at the intersection of the history of ideas, the history of technology and economic and social history, it has the potential advantage of drawing attention from more than one quarter, but it also runs the risk of being ignored, because it does not, after all, lie in anyone's domain. The growing cross-frontier traffic between historical disciplines in recent years has rescued the subject from neglect in this no-man's land, however. Craft secrecy has turned out to be a relevant issue in various, partly related debates in medieval and early modern history, which have developed since the late 1980s. Both in the context of discussions on the origins of patents and notions of and in the renewed debates surrounding the history of guilds and corporations and technological innovation in the pre-modern period, craft secrecy has come to be recognized as an interesting and significant phenomenon. The scholar who has done most to highlight the importance of this theme is historian Pamela Long. Long has situated the evolution of craft secrecy in the framework of a broader history of key concepts related to the idea of intellectual property such as openness, secrecy, ownership and authorship, which transcend traditional boundaries between historical disciplines. None of these concepts was in the pre-modern period naturally accepted as a central value, she argued. Neither 'openness' nor 'secrecy' at this time enjoyed the status of a self-evident, general principle. The idea of a right on knowledge only gradually took shape as a product of a contingent combination of historical circumstances and a fusion of different traditions of