The American Statistician · 2003 · 125 citations · 30 references
Public HealthBiostatisticsPsychologyExperimental DesignItem Response TheoryPsychometricsEffect Size EstimationExternal ValidityHealth Status MeasurementHypothesis TestingModerator AnalysisPsychological TestingAlcohol Consumption PatternsCeiling RelationshipsHealth Status IndicesHealth Status InstrumentsLinear RegressionSignificance CriteriaType Ii Error AnalysisType Ii Error Rate Control
Many variables in biomedical research (e.g., indices of health status) are measured with ceiling effects, in which a substantial number of subjects attain the highest possible scale value because the scale only discriminates among individuals in the low to moderate range. Furthermore, in social surveys, variables such as income and alcohol consumption may be subject to ceiling effects to protect the privacy and identity of those at the upper end of the distribution for a given variable. This article shows that if one attempts to control for such a variable using ordinary linear regression, and then test another independent variable that is actually unrelated to the outcome, the result can be an increase in the rate of Type I Error (false significance). We present simulations in which standard tests conducted at the 5%% significance level actually have the Type I error rates approaching 100%% for large samples. Statistical solutions are explored, but the best recommendation is to construct scales that are not subject to ceiling effects.
30
Dialnet (Universidad de la Rioja) · 1978 · 6.8K citations
Leonard I. Pearlin, Carmi Schooler · Journal of Health and Social Behavior · 1978 · 5.5K citations
Education, Psychology, Self +6
Leonard A. Stefanski, Wayne A. Fuller, John Wiley · Journal of Business and Economic Statistics · 1988 · 2.9K citations
Statistical Models and Methods for Lifetime Data.
Brian Francis, Jerald F. Lawless · Biometrics · 1983 · 2.8K citations
Public Health, Biostatistics, Aging +13