Behavioral Sciences & the Law · 2006 · 48 citations · 12 references
LawHealth LawJurisprudenceLegal InterpretationLegal ReasoningMental Health LawInterpretation Of Legal TextsLegal Discourse AnalysisClinical InsightFlexibilityInsight ScalesInterpretive FlexibilityJudicial Commitment HearingsJurisprudence Of InterpretationSocial ContextTherapeutic Jurisprudence
This research investigates how the term "insight" was employed in 25 decisions from mental health review proceedings in Victoria, Australia. The application of insight appears problematic in these decisions. First, there is little clarification of its meaning. Second, the logic applied when insight is related to compliance is often unclear. Third, there are frequent allusions to an implicit and undefined scale of insight, offering the appearance of objectivity. We have analysed insight as an 'interpretive resource', focusing on its various functions in the complex social context of commitment hearings and with a view to its therapeutic jurisprudence implications. The variable application of insight-its interpretive flexibility-appears useful in addressing complex problems faced by review boards. Hence, a key function of insight is to bridge between legal and clinical discourses. Insight is also a convenient means to avoid complicated debates regarding the person's credibility. By analysing insight in Victoria, we hope to contribute to better theoretical understanding of decision-making patterns in mental health law in general.
12
Anthony F. C. Wallace, Harold Garfinkel · American Sociological Review · 1968 · 12.6K citations
Principles of Critical Discourse Analysis
Teun A. van Dijk · Discourse & Society · 1993 · 4.9K citations
Nordic Journal of Psychiatry · 1999 · 122 citations
Reappraising insight in psychosis
Manuel J. Cuesta, Víctor Peralta, Amalia Zarzuela · The British Journal of Psychiatry · 2000 · 109 citations · Full text