A Prospective Study of the Cost-Utility of the Multichannel Cochlear Implant

TLDR

Prior clinical studies have shown that cochlear implantation benefits individuals with advanced sensorineural hearing loss who cannot achieve effective speech recognition with hearing aids. The study aims to determine the cost per quality‑adjusted life‑year for adults receiving multichannel cochlear implants. The authors conducted a prospective 12‑month multicenter study of adults with severe to profound hearing loss, collecting health‑utility data via the Health Utility Index and medical resource utilization, and built a decision model to estimate cost per QALY. Multichannel cochlear implants produced a 0.20 gain in health‑utility within 12 months—90% of which occurred by 6 months—and yielded a favorable cost per QALY of $14,670 for a 22‑year life expectancy, while markedly improving speech understanding and health‑utility ratings.

Abstract

Prior clinical studies have indicated that cochlear implantation provides benefits to individuals with advanced sensorineural hearing loss who are unable to gain effective speech recognition with hearing aids.To determine the cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) for adults receiving multichannel cochlear implants.Prospective 12-month multicenter study using preference-based quality-of-life measures and total cost determinations, comparing profoundly hearing-impaired adult subjects with and without cochlear implants.Hospital-based and patient-resource clinics.Severely to profoundly hearing-impaired adult recipients of a cochlear implant and adults eligible for the device who had not yet received it.Clinical assessment of implant participants included medical and audiologic (speech understanding) data at the time of enrollment, 6 months, and 12 months. All participants' health-utility was assessed at the time of enrollment, 6 months, and 12 months using the Health Utility Index. One-year medical resource utilization and cost data included bills related to implants, patient diaries, charge estimates from clinical sites, and published literature. A decision model was developed to determine cost per QALY.Of the 84 enrolled adults, 62 (75%) completed the study. Mean health-utility scores at the time of enrollment were identical between groups. The marginal 12-month health-utility gain for implant recipients was 0.20; 90% of this improvement was achieved within 6 months. For patients with a mean 22-year life expectancy, the marginal cost per QALY was $14,670.Overall, multichannel cochlear implants significantly improved recipients' performance on measures of speech understanding and ratings of health-utility within 6 months of implantation. The multichannel cochlear implant yielded a very favorable cost per QALY.