Development and Change · 2007 · 243 citations · 38 references
Social SciencesEntrepreneurshipSociologyAfrican StudiesDevelopment EconomicsSocial InequalityMineral Resource GovernanceMineral Resource ManagementMining LawMining PolicyOwnership Of Mineral EstatesPostcolonial African StatesArtisanal And Small-scale Mining PolicyArtisanal Mining GovernanceArtisanal Mining PolicyMarginal AllocationOccupation Of MineralsSocial Exclusion TheorySpatial Power RelationsUnequal Access
Artisanal miners in sub‑Saharan Africa occupy a marginal position, and institutional and legal integration of mineral titles conceals social and power relations that perpetuate unequal access to resources. The study uses the concept of social exclusion to examine how marginalization affects access to mineral resources and livelihoods in Tanzanian diamond and gold mining, and argues that addressing marginality requires recognizing local organizations and relationships that underpin inequalities. The authors analyze diamond and gold mining in Tanzania by applying the concept of social exclusion to assess how marginalization affects access to mineral resources and livelihoods. The study finds that legal integration benefits wealthier entrepreneurs but leaves others dependent, exploited, and insecure, illustrating the complex socio‑economic consequences of marginalization.
ABSTRACT This article examines the marginal position of artisanal miners in sub‐Saharan Africa, and considers how they are incorporated into mineral sector change in the context of institutional and legal integration. Taking the case of diamond and gold mining in Tanzania, the concept of social exclusion is used to explore the consequences of marginalization on people's access to mineral resources and ability to make a living from artisanal mining. Because existing inequalities and forms of discrimination are ignored by the Tanzanian state, the institutionalization of mineral titles conceals social and power relations that perpetuate highly unequal access to resources. The article highlights the complexity of these processes, and shows that while legal integration can benefit certain wealthier categories of people, who fit into the model of an ‘entrepreneurial small‐scale miner’, for others adverse incorporation contributes to socio‐economic dependence, exploitation and insecurity. For the issue of marginality to be addressed within integration processes, the existence of local forms of organization, institutions and relationships, which underpin inequalities and discrimination, need to be recognized.
38