HumanitiesPhilosophyExperimental DesignExperimental PsychologyLogicModal LogicModal SemanticsAristotle's LogicExperimental PhilosophyModal ResponsePropositional InferencePropositional ReasoningScopeScope Comparison
Two experiments (N1 = 141, N2 = 40) investigate two versions of Aristotle's Thesis for the first time. Aristotle's Thesis is a negated conditional, which consists of one propositional variable with a negation either in the antecedent (version 1) or in the consequent (version 2). This task allows us to infer if people interpret indicative conditionals as material conditionals or as conditional events. In the first experiment I investigate between-participants the two versions of Aristotle's Thesis crossed with abstract versus concrete task material. The modal response for all four groups is consistent with the conditional event and inconsistent with the material conditional interpretation. This observation is replicated in the second experiment. Moreover, the second experiment rules out scope ambiguities of the negation of conditionals. Both experiments provide new evidence against die material conditional interpretation of conditionals and support the conditional event interpretation. Finally, I discuss implications for modeling indicative conditionals and the relevance of this work for experimental philosophy.
19
Human reasoning: the psychology of deduction
Choice Reviews Online · 1994 · 996 citations
The probability of causal conditionals
David E. Over, Constantinos Hadjichristidis, Jonathan St. B. T. Evans et al. · Cognitive Psychology · 2006 · 227 citations · Full text