Self-Reported Health in Relation to Medical Health and Gender-Specific Problems in Women

Abstract

Self-reported health was studied in relation to physiological measures, gender-specific problems, and clinical evaluation in 61 middle-aged women employed in a male-dominated industry. Using self-reported somatic health as the dependent variable, 50% of the variability was explained by the dimension workplace culture and the ratio low-density lipoprotein/high-density lipoprotein. Some women who reported good health were diagnosed with distress but showed no ill-health factors. However, they reported experiences of gender-specific problems more often than the women who were diagnosed as being healthy. We concluded that self-report scales seem not to be enough to identify people who look healthy on standard health scales but who use psychological defenses. Differentiating methods such as gender-specific questions, physiological ratio-measures, and clinical judgment seem to be important for distinguishing genuine from illusory mental or physical health.