International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction · 1992 · 83 citations · 24 references
ArtsComputer ScienceErgonomicsHuman-computer InteractionUser Experience DesignErgonomic AssessmentHuman-machine InterfacesInterface DesignUsability EngineeringUsability EvaluationUsability TestingHuman-computer Interface DesignInterface EvaluationUsability Problem ClassificationUsability Problems IdentificationUser Interface Ergonomics
The study validates ergonomic criteria for evaluating human‑computer interfaces through an experimental test. The experiment involved 24 participants who identified violated criteria from 18 elementary options for 36 usability problems, testing the previously defined ergonomic criteria. The experiment found no group differences, with an average 59.85 % correct identification, indicating that while some criteria need refinement, the approach is feasible for evaluating interfaces.
This article presents the results of an experiment designed to validate a set of ergonomic criteria for the evaluation of human‐computer interfaces. Criteria definitions that were designed in a previous study, were tested in a concept‐identification task. Twenty‐four subjects (12 human factors specialists and 12 nonspecialists) were asked to identify the criterion, within a set of 18 elementary criteria, that was violated for each of 36 usability problems. The results show no difference between groups either in terms of performance times or correct identifications. The mean percentage of correct identifications was 59.85%. This result calls for the refinement of some definitions. A detailed examination of the data and an analysis of confusion matrices permits the identification of categories of well‐defined criteria and categories of criteria that would benefit from improvements in their definitions. These results seem to support the feasibility of an evaluation method based on explicitely defined criteria.
24
Designing the user interface: Strategies for effective human-computer interaction
Applied Ergonomics · 1993 · 5.6K citations
Arts, Computer Science, Design +14
Heuristic evaluation of user interfaces
Jakob Nielsen, Rolf Molich · 1990 · 3.4K citations
Improving a human-computer dialogue
Rolf Molich, Jakob Nielsen · Communications of the ACM · 1990 · 816 citations
User interface evaluation in the real world
Robin Jeffries, James R. Miller, Cathleen Wharton et al. · 1991 · 620 citations