Evolution of Insect/Host Plant Relationships

T. Jermy

The American Naturalist · 1984 · 494 citations · 103 references

Concepts

Abstract

The evolutionary interactions between plants and phytophagous insects are asymmetric: the biochemical and structural diversity of the angiosperms provide a profusion of niches for the evolutionary radiation (cladogenesis) of the insects, while the insects do not affect plant evolution or, at most, may cause anagenic changes in the plants. (Figwasps and figs may represent a rare case of coevolution sensu stricto.) Thus, the evolution of insects generally follows that of the plants ("sequential evolution"). Because the selection pressure exerted by insect attacks is weak or lacking, they could not have been the main cause of the appearance and maintenance of allelochemicals in plants. Nevertheless, these compounds basically determine the plants' "biochemical profile" by which the insects distinguish between host and nonhost plants. Interspecific competition is largely lacking among phytophagous insects in natural communities, so it could not have evoked stenophagy (i.e., resource partitioning) in the insects. The dominance of stenophagous forms can be explained by (1) the adaptive advantages of stenophagy over euryphagy; (2) the emergence of new stenophagous forms from similar or euryphagous forms; and (3) the evolutionary irreversibility of developing stenophagy. Thus, plants have not become resistant to insects, but the insect species have become, or were ever since their emergence, particular in food selection. Host plant selection is mainly a behavioral process which is governed primarily by chemoreception. Therefore, the emergence of specific insect/host plant relationships most likely results from evolutionary changes in the insects' chemosensory systems. Adaptation to the nutritional quality of the new host plant is a secondary process.

References

103